# TradingSim Alternatives: Replay Simulators Compared

Source: https://www.tradicted.com/learn/tradingsim-alternatives/
Published: 2026-11-11

---
The closest TradingSim alternative is another replay tool: TradingView Bar Replay, Simul8or or the free Tradicted day trading simulator. Live-data broker paper accounts train something else, because TradingSim exists to replay past sessions at a speed you choose.

The replay tools split on history depth, smallest replay unit and price. I checked each price on the vendor's own page on November 11, 2026.

### Key Takeaways

- TradingSim's closest alternatives are replay tools such as TradingView Bar Replay, Simul8or and Tradicted's free browser simulator, and live-data broker paper accounts belong to a separate category.
- TradingSim costs $79 or $89 a month, or $33 or $37 a month billed annually, and its Premium plan adds Level 2, tick and second charts and 5 years of history (prices as of November 11, 2026).
- TradingView Bar Replay history depends on the plan, from about 6 months of 1-minute bars on Essential to the symbol's full history on Premium and above, and TradingView states that orders placed during replay execute on real-time data.
- Replay practice trains execution and cannot show whether a strategy has an edge, so the cost worth tracking is the price per session you complete.

## What does a TradingSim alternative need to do?

A market replay simulator is software that plays back recorded price data from a past trading session at a speed the trader controls, so simulated orders can be placed as if the session were live. TradingSim is one.

Replay compresses time. You can run the first hour after the 9:30 AM ET open in a few minutes, reset, and run a different day. A live paper account moves at the market's pace, which gives you real-time pressure and far fewer repetitions per hour.

| | Replay simulator | Live paper account |
|---|---|---|
| What drives the price | Recorded data from a past session | The live market |
| Session speed | Adjustable | Real time |
| Repetitions per hour | Many | Few |
| Outcome already happened | Yes | No |
| What it trains best | Execution and pattern repetitions | Patience and real-time decisions |

![Timeline chart of 60 minutes: six 10-minute replay sessions at 10x speed against one continuous live session](/learn/tradingsim-alternatives/replay-vs-live-one-hour.webp)

This article stays with the replay simulator. Broker paper accounts such as thinkorswim paperMoney, Webull and Interactive Brokers have their own page of [live-data broker paper accounts compared](/learn/best-day-trading-simulators/). Beginners can start with [how paper trading works](/learn/what-is-paper-trading/).

## How do TradingSim alternatives compare on price, history and data?

TradingSim sells two plans, and the table sets both against three replay alternatives on the columns that decide a purchase.

| Tool | Price | Replay history | Smallest replay unit | Markets | Account needed | Free option |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TradingSim Pro | $79 per month, or $33 per month billed annually | 2 years | Tick and second charts not included | Equities, futures, crypto | Yes | 7-day free trial |
| TradingSim Premium | $89 per month, or $37 per month billed annually | 5 years | Tick and second charts, plus Level 2 and 15-minute delayed live sessions | Equities, futures, crypto | Yes | 7-day free trial |
| TradingView Bar Replay | $12.95 to $199.95 per month billed annually (Essential to Ultimate) | Depends on plan and interval | One bar, no smaller segments. Tick Replay on Ultimate only | The symbols TradingView charts | Yes | Free Basic plan exists |
| Simul8or | Free. Pro $9 per month, $67 per year or $19 lifetime | - | Full speed range (0.25x to 10x) on Pro and Elite | Stocks, with separate forex, crypto and prediction-market simulators | No | Yes, limited access |
| Tradicted Day Trading Simulator | Free | One session on real market structure, ticker and dates hidden | Streaming candles | Real historical market structure | No | Yes |

TradingSim lists Pro at $79 and Premium at $89 a month, with "annual discounts available". Its trial page gives the annual rates, the history depths and the 7-day trial. TradingView's figures come from its pricing page and its support article on Bar Replay data limits, and the Simul8or row from Simul8or's site.

![Bar chart of replay history: TradingView Essential about 6 months, Plus about 1 year, TradingSim Pro 2 years, Premium 5 years, TradingView Premium full history](/learn/tradingsim-alternatives/replay-history-depth.webp)

Read the history column before the price column. A $33 TradingSim plan with 2 years and a $12.95 TradingView plan with about 6 months of 1-minute bars cover different days.

## Which TradingSim alternative fits which kind of trader?

The right pick depends on whether you need tick-level detail, already pay for TradingView, or want a free tool with no account. Fit by need:

- Level 2, tick and second charts and 5 years of history point to TradingSim Premium, and none of the alternatives here replaces it.
- A trader already paying for TradingView Premium or higher gets Bar Replay back to the start of a symbol's data at no extra cost.
- Free replay with no account is what Simul8or offers, with the full speed range kept for its paid plans.
- Practicing price reading without knowing the ticker or the date fits the Tradicted day trading simulator, which hides both.
- Replaying one specific stock on one specific day needs TradingSim or TradingView Bar Replay, since the Tradicted simulator does not let you choose either.

The two TradingSim plans sit $10 a month apart, or $4 a month billed annually. That gap buys Level 2, tick and second charts, delayed live sessions and 3 more years of history.

## What does TradingSim do better than its alternatives?

TradingSim replays real historical tick-by-tick data from US exchanges (Nasdaq, NYSE, AMEX, CME, CBOT, NYMEX, COMEX) across more than 10,000 US equity symbols plus futures and crypto, according to TradingSim. Neither free tool in this comparison claims exchange tick data.

Both plans include "Markets & replay", which TradingSim's trial page describes as "Replay historical sessions and practice simulated trades". Journal and tags come with each.

TradingSim's homepage lists the replay controls. A Replay Rail lets you click an execution to jump back to it. You can step bar by bar, or jump to the open, Power Hour, the close or a typed time.

Bookmarks take notes and tags. A "Start fresh" option separates attempts at the same session, and you can export clips. Fee modeling uses broker-style presets or custom flat and per-share charges.

The homepage also states the limits. Leverage from 1x to 10x is the one item labelled beta.

Crypto trades are market orders only, with no short selling. Forex is missing from the market list, and the free trial lasts 7 days.

## TradingSim vs TradingView Bar Replay

TradingView Bar Replay is a charting feature that hides the bars after a chosen date and reveals them one at a time, so a trader can review a chart as the session unfolds.

TradingSim is built for simulated execution on tick data. Bar Replay is chart review, with history depth set by your TradingView plan and interval.

Entry prices differ too. TradingView Essential costs $12.95 a month billed annually, against $33 for TradingSim Pro on the same billing.

### How far back can TradingView replay?

| TradingView plan | Price (billed annually) | 1-minute replay history | Seconds intervals | Tick Replay |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $0 | Bar Replay inclusion not stated | No | No |
| Essential | $12.95 per month | About 6 months (5-minute bars: about 30 months) | No | No |
| Plus | $29.95 per month | About 1 year | No | No |
| Premium | $59.95 per month | Back to the start of the symbol's data | Yes | No |
| Ultimate | $199.95 per month | Back to the start of the symbol's data | Yes | Yes, up to 7 days back |

TradingView's support article "How much data is available for Bar Replay?" sets these limits, and the prices come from TradingView's pricing page.

Daily bars replay all available data on every plan. On Essential, the intraday window grows with the interval, at roughly the interval in minutes times 6 months. Five-minute bars reach about 30 months.

The Expert plan sits with Premium and Ultimate for full intraday history. TradingView gives August 17, 2022 as the earliest 1-second bar in replay.

### Why do TradingView replay orders execute on real-time data?

TradingView Bar Replay executes your orders on real-time data, not on the past bar your screen shows.

TradingView's support page "What is Bar Replay?" says so in one line: "Trading orders execute on real-time data, including in Paper Trading." The same page adds, "It's not possible to replay bars in smaller segments."

Chart types are limited too. Renko, Kagi, Point and Figure, Range, Line Break, volume footprint, TPO and tick-based charts do not work with Bar Replay.

That makes Bar Replay a tool for reading charts. You can study how a setup developed bar by bar, and you cannot rehearse the fill.

## Is Simul8or a good free TradingSim alternative?

Simul8or is a good free alternative for practicing order mechanics, and a weak one for anything that depends on exact prices. It is a free stock simulator that replays past sessions or live prices with no account.

Simul8or's own site says its data "may be delayed, inaccurate, or simplified". You can go long or short.

The simulator tracks P&L, win rate and an equity curve. It runs on the web, on Windows through the Microsoft Store, on Android and on Linux, with Chrome and Edge extensions.

Speed costs extra. Simul8or's upgrade page lists all replay speeds, from 0.25x to 10x, under Pro and Elite, and describes free use as "limited access".

Pro costs $9 a month, $67 a year or $19 one time for lifetime access. The Elite price is not listed.

Simplified data works for learning how a stop order behaves. I would not use it to set stop distance against real tick-level movement, and that is the job TradingSim's exchange data is sold for.

### What to use instead of Simul8or

For exchange tick data, TradingSim is the step up from Simul8or. TradingView Bar Replay on Premium or above reaches back to the start of a symbol's data. The Tradicted day trading simulator stays free and hides both the ticker and the date.

## How does the Tradicted day trading simulator differ from TradingSim?

Disclosure first. I build the Tradicted day trading simulator, and Tradicted publishes this article.

The Tradicted simulator is a [free browser day trading simulator](/tools/day-trading-simulator/) that plays one session on real historical market structure, with the ticker and dates hidden. It needs no download, login or sign-up.

Candles stream in as the session plays. You can go long or short, stack up to five positions each way and flatten. The results screen shows realized P&L, trade count, max drawdown and peak equity.

![Screenshot of the Tradicted day trading simulator mid-session: a falling candlestick chart with no ticker, a short position of 3, and Sell, Flatten and Buy buttons](/learn/tradingsim-alternatives/day-trading-simulator-session.webp)

The browser version has no order routing, Level 2 or options chain. The full version is Lightning Mode in the Tradicted app on [iOS](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/stock-trading-game-simulator/id6739497557) and [Android](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mycompany.tradicted), free, with no ads and unlimited sessions.

Hiding the ticker and date removes the hindsight of knowing how a famous day ended. The cost is control.

You cannot pick a ticker or a date, and there is no tick data or fee modeling. For rehearsing a specific setup on a chosen stock and day, TradingSim stays the better tool.

## Is DayTradeLab a replay simulator?

No. DayTradeLab is a free learning site run by a London-based trader, and its site does not mention replay.

It offers guides, a Discord, a "Practice Tools" section and five named tools (P&L Tracker, Candle Countdown, Risk Calculator, Market Countdown and Chart Snipper Pro). The site says "Everything here is free to use."

If you want replay, TradingSim, TradingView Bar Replay and Simul8or replace DayTradeLab. Free calculators and lessons are a different need, outside the replay category.

## What does replay practice cost per session?

Cost per session equals the monthly price divided by the replay sessions you complete that month, so TradingSim Pro at $79 a month used for 50 sessions costs $1.58 a session. Fifty sessions is a little over two per trading day.

**Cost per session = monthly price / sessions completed per month**

| TradingSim plan | Monthly price | 50 sessions | 8 sessions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pro | $79 | $1.58 | $9.88 |
| Pro, billed annually | $33 | $0.66 | $4.13 |
| Premium | $89 | $1.78 | $11.13 |
| Premium, billed annually | $37 | $0.74 | $4.63 |

At 8 sessions a month, about two a week, TradingSim Pro at $79 a month costs $9.88 a session. That is 15 times the $0.66 a trader pays running 50 sessions a month on the annual plan.

| Tool and plan | First-year cost | Arithmetic |
|---|---|---|
| TradingSim Pro, $79 per month | $948 | $79 x 12 |
| TradingSim Pro, annual rate | $396 | $33 x 12 |
| TradingSim Premium, $89 per month | $1,068 | $89 x 12 |
| TradingSim Premium, annual rate | $444 | $37 x 12 |
| TradingView Plus | $359.40 | $29.95 x 12, billed annually |
| TradingView Premium | $719.40 | $59.95 x 12, billed annually |
| TradingView Ultimate | $2,399.40 | $199.95 x 12, billed annually |
| Simul8or Pro | $108 monthly, $67 yearly or $19 lifetime | $9 x 12 for monthly |
| Tradicted Day Trading Simulator | $0 | Free |

![Bar chart of first-year cost: TradingSim Pro $948 monthly or $396 annual, Premium $1,068 or $444, TradingView up to $2,399, Simul8or $108, Tradicted $0](/learn/tradingsim-alternatives/replay-first-year-cost.webp)

The annual rate is $552 below twelve times the $79 list price on Pro ($948 minus $396) and $624 below twelve times the $89 list price on Premium ($1,068 minus $444).

Your session count moves the per-session cost more than the plan does. A $396 year of TradingSim Pro at 8 sessions a month still works out to $4.13 a session.

## What can replay practice not teach?

Replay practice trains execution, meaning entries, exits and order handling under time pressure, and it cannot tell you [whether a strategy has positive expectancy](/learn/expectancy-in-trading/). A hundred clean replay entries say nothing about the edge behind them.

None of the vendor pages cited here claims that its replay models your own order moving the price, or your place in a limit order queue.

You also know the session already happened. A losing replay trade is easier to hold, because the day closed long ago and no money moves.

History depth is gated by plan on TradingSim and TradingView, so check which days you can replay before comparing headline prices. TradingSim Pro stops at 2 years, and TradingView Essential at about 6 months of 1-minute bars.
